Thursday, August 28, 2008

Border talks postponed

Courtesy of Straits Times - Singapore

PHNOM PENH - ANTI-government protests in Bangkok have caused the Thai military to postpone talks to discuss withdrawing troops from a disputed border area near an ancient temple, a Cambodian general said on Thursday.

Twenty soldiers from Cambodia and Thailand remain stationed at a small pagoda on a patch of disputed land near Cambodia's Preah Vihear temple, while 40 from both sides remain nearby.

Up to 1,000 Cambodian and Thai troops pulled back from the area in mid-August, suggesting that an end to the sometimes tense month-long military stand-off could be near.

But Cambodian and Thai military officials scheduled to meet Friday to discuss a further pullback of troops postponed their talks at the request of Thai officials, Cambodian General Neang Phat, a secretary of state at the defence ministry, told sources on Thursday.

The request was made Wednesday afternoon, just hours after a 30-member Thai delegation arrived in Siem Reap to prepare for the talks, he said.

'They requested the meeting be postponed and they returned to Thailand,' General Neang Phat said.

'They did not give any reasons. But we can know that it is because of their internal problems,' he added.

Thai officials were not immediately available to confirm the suspension of the talks.

Thousands of Thai protesters seized a television station and occupied the the main government compound in Bangkok this week in an attempt to force the resignation of Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej.

Courts have ordered the protesters out of Government House and issued arrest warrants for nine of the movement's leaders, but the demonstrators remained defiant Thursday.

General Neang Phat said it was not clear when Thai and Cambodian military officials would resume the meeting to discuss troop withdrawals.

After talks last week between Thai Foreign Minister Tej Bunnag and his Cambodian counterpart Hor Namhong, the two sides said a border committee would meet in October to step up efforts to draw the boundary around the temple.

Cambodia had asked the UN Security Council to consider the standoff that erupted in July, but Mr Hor Namhong said that request would likely be withdrawn.

Relations between the neighbours flared up last month after Preah Vihear was awarded world heritage status by the UN cultural body UNESCO, angering nationalists in Thailand who still claim ownership of the ancient Khmer temple.

On July 15, Cambodia arrested three Thai protesters for illegally crossing the border to try to reach the temple, sparking the deployment of troops from both sides on the tiny patch of disputed land near Preah Vihear.

The International Court of Justice ruled in 1962 that the Preah Vihear temple belongs to Cambodia, but the surrounding land remains in dispute. -- AFP

Baby Born With Two Heads Has Police Protection Due To Crowds


A BABY boy born with two heads has been placed under police protection because of the curiosity his birth has caused.

"Around 150,000 people gathered yesterday from different areas. It became tough for us to care for the baby,'' gynaecologist Mohamad Abdul Bari said.

The baby, named Kiron, was born by Caesarean section on Monday weighing 5.5 kilograms in Keshobpur, 135 kilometres from Dhaka, Bangladesh.

"He has one stomach and he is eating normally with his two mouths. He has one genital organ and a full set of limbs,'' said Dr Bari.

"He was born from one embryo but there was a developmental anomaly.''

The clinic had been unable to determine whether the baby had one or two sets of vital organs, Dr Bari said.

The baby's life was not in immediate danger but he and his mother, 22, had been moved to a larger hospital in nearby Jessore city because of the large crowds that had gathered at the clinic, he said.

"We called police to tackle the situation and they are guarding the hospital in Jessore as well,'' he said.

Many well-wishers had left money for the baby's family outside the hospital.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

BANKING - KTB Seeks Presence In Sihanoukville

Bangkok Post
Garment, tourism businesses targeted

NAREERAT WIRIYAPONG

PHNOM PENH : State-owned Krung Thai Bank is looking to expand its presence in Cambodia by opening a new branch in the port town of Sihanoukville. Sihanoukville, about 230 kilometres southwest of Phnom Penh, is considered a strategic location for the new branch of KTB as it is the centre of logistics, trade and investment, as well as tourism, said Pisit Buranakitpinyo, general manager and vice-president of KTB's Phnom Penh branch.

The Thai bank, which has had a presence in Cambodia since 1994, currently operates two branches in the country _ one in Phnom Penh and a sub-branch in Siem Reap.

''The deep-sea port at Sihanoukville has created a big volume of business transactions including shipments of goods exported from Thailand, China and Vietnam,'' said Mr Pisit.

''At the same time, factories, mainly those in the garment industry, are operated there while beaches have led to developments of tourism businesses around the area.''

Garments are the biggest industry in Cambodia since it has enjoyed tariff privileges from exporting to the US market. Through the operations of roughly 300 factories, garments accounted for a major share of Cambodia's gross domestic product (GDP), noted Mr Pisit.

According to the Office of Commercial Affairs of the Thai embassy in Phnom Penh, a cluster of 20 Chinese garment factories in Sihanoukville takes advantage of cheap labour and tariff privileges for exporting to the US.

Siam Commercial Bank (SCB), which operates in Cambodia under the name Cambodian Commercial Bank, has four branches at present including the one in Sihanoukville, Mr Pisit said.

According to Mr Pisit, Cambodia is currently the biggest overseas operation of KTB, which operates 200 branches locally. The bank has one branch each in Vientiane, Mumbai, Kunming, Singapore and Los Angeles. The two branches in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City had been closed.

''Cambodia is one of the emerging markets that have high potential,'' he said, citing the country's double-digit growth rates seen over the past decade. ''But this year, the (Cambodian) economy is likely to expand below 10% due to high oil prices and the global economic slowdown.

''The government here has introduced aggressive economic measures, for example the establishment of a stock exchange by the end of next year. Laws and regulations have been adjusted to facilitate the plan,'' he added.

On the bank's performance, Mr Pisit said first-half results remained on target despite tensions over Thailand's border with Cambodia.

''So far, I think we are still on track to achieve the whole year's target,'' he said but decline to elaborate the figures.

KTB shares closed yesterday on the SET at 7.50 baht, up 10 satang, in trade worth 112.13 million baht.

Chinese Investment Pouring Into Thailand's Neighbours

The Nation: August 28, 2008 : Last updated 03:37 pm

China has been the beneficiary of huge foreign direct investment. But in recent years, the tables have turned, and China has becomes a prominent foreign investor in Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos.

Earlier this year, China's Commerce Ministry predicted foreign investment by Chinese enterprises would likely exceed US$20.9 billion (Bt707 billion) this year, up at least 30 per cent from last year, as Beijing continues to encourage Chinese companies to expand abroad.

China's direct foreign investment began to soar in 2005, when the figure jumped 123 per cent year on year to $12.3 billion. The Commerce Ministry's 11th five-year plan, which began last year, predicts aggregate direct foreign investment by Chinese companies will top $60 billion by 2010.

A considerable slice of that investment is going to Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos - Thailand's neighbours - which are building their economies from scratch.

In Cambodia, China was the dominant foreign investor last year, with $763 million in investment approvals - nearly double its 2005 total. Russia was a distant second last year, with approvals totalling $278 million.

In Laos between 2001 and this past August, Chinese foreign direct investment in projects approved by the Lao Committee for Planning and Investment amounted to $1.1 billion, second only to Thailand's projects, worth $1.3 billion.

In Vietnam, Chinese investment skyrocketed from $66 million in 2005 to $312 million last year.

Chinese investment in Cambodia has been welcomed with open arms following a decades-long relationship. The Chinese government is pouring money into bridges and roads - it donated $6 million worth of steel bridges to Cambodia in 2001 - and has pledged military assistance in the form of new vessels for the country's dilapidated navy. Cambodia's revered former king, Norodom Sihanouk, spends months at a time in Beijing, and Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao showed the value he placed on the relationship in April 2006, when he included Cambodia in a tour of New Zealand and Australia. China also agreed to waive outstanding loans to Cambodia five years ago.

These days, China's emphasis on Cambodia is increasingly looking beyond aid towards desperately needed investment. Chinese, and now Cambodian investors, are planting hectares of biofuel crops like jatropha, which Chinese industry devours insatiably. Recently, a Chinese company signed a deal to grow mulberries over a tract of land in southern Cambodia as a resource from which to supply raw silk to its factories and offered to build a factory to process the silk-worm cocoons in country.

In May, China's fifth-largest steelmaker, Wuhan Steel, announced it had joined the Anshan Iron and Steel Group, Shanghai's Baosteel Group and Beijing's Shougang Iron and Steel Group to explore for iron ore in Cambodia's remote northern province of Preah Vihear - on the border with Thailand.

Earlier this year, an investor was given the go-ahead for a $215-million hydroelectric plant in the coastal province of Koh Kong. Huot Pongan, Cambodia's under-secretary of state for industry, mines and energy, says the benefits outweigh the risks.

"We don't have enough electricity. China is developing that for us. We don't have the resources to build mines and harvest our resources. China does. And China has been here for a long time and will stay here for a long time," he says.

In Laos, besides investments in hydroelectric plants, Chinese companies are also investing in mining, rubber plantations, telecommunications, construction materials, hotels and restaurants. In August, Chinese investors opened the China Market near Vientiane Airport. It is now one of the biggest shopping malls in the capital. Chinese merchants man the stalls, and Chinese goods are on sale.

The huge increase in Chinese investments in mining and hydropower plants has led to a two-year moratorium on new concessions. Laos has handed out more than 140 mining concessions in recent years, many to Chinese enterprises looking for gold, copper, iron, potassium and bauxite.

For instance, Australia's Ord River Resources has joined China's Non-ferrous Metals International Mining to develop a 727-square-kilometre concession on the Bolaven Plateau in southern Laos into one of the world's largest bauxite mines, for the manufacture of aluminium. Such concessions are hard to secure in Laos without a Chinese partner.

"It's political," says Vinay Inthavong, a Lao entrepreneur and chairman of the Vico Group. "If the leadership wants to stay in power, they have to support China and Vietnam."

In Vietnam, Yang Dewei, 42, manager of a factory called United Motor Vietnam, explains: "Doing business here is pretty much the same as in China, except for the language difference."

For Chinese investors, Vietnam's economic climate has the advantage of familiarity: a fellow communist country implementing economic reforms, plus an emerging middle class eager to consume basic and luxury goods.

This explains why Chinese companies invested in 57 projects in Vietnam last year, up from 40 in 2005. At least 250 Chinese investment projects have been established in the last five years, says Vietnam's Planning and Investment Ministry.

China remains a relatively small investor in Vietnam, ranking 13th behind top investors South Korea, Singapore, Taiwan and Japan. But Vietnam has been a major location for China's outsourcing factories.

In 2005, the last year for which detailed figures are available, about 35 per cent of Chinese investment in Vietnam was in manufacturing, while in 2004 that sector represented 83 per cent of Chinese investments. The balance of investment - and the other pillar of China's move into Vietnam - reflects its priorities elsewhere in the world: natural resources.

Investment in projects like coal extraction and bauxite mining made up 44 per cent of Chinese investment in Vietnam in 2005, up from only 3 per cent the year before.

Still, for Chinese manufacturers like Yang Dewei, Vietnam's low wages, geographical proximity and cultural similarity make the country an attractive place to export factories.

"It's not exactly the same," he says. "For instance, in my home town of Chongqing, in southern China, the people eat spicy food, and I have a hard time finding good food here. But I am here for the business, and so far it's worth it."

//by Deutsche Presse-Agentur

Cambodia, Thai Border Talks Postponed Due To Bangkok Protests

The Nation: Thu, August 28, 2008 : Last updated 13:10 hours
By Deutsche Presse Agenture

Phnom Penh - Informal talks between Bangkok and Phnom Penh over disputed border areas were halted abruptly and scheduled formal talks postponed indefinitely amid political tension in Thailand, a Cambodian official said Thursday.


Defence Ministry Secretary of State Neang Phat said the Thai delegation arrived Wednesday in Siem Reap, 300 kilometres north of Phnom Penh, and the two sides had talked amicably before formal talks scheduled for Friday were abruptly cancelled.


"We had prepared all the documents," Phat said. "Then a call came and they asked for the meeting to be delayed. They didn't say why but we can assume. This is Thailand's business, not ours."


Phat was referring to the ongoing anti-government protests in Bangkok by the Thai opposition People's Alliance for Democracy movement, which escalated Tuesday.


Phat said no new date had been set for a resumption of joint talks over border areas around the newly listed UNESCO World Heritage site of Preah Vihear temple, as well as the Ta Moan temple complex 150 kilometres to its west.


Thailand maintains the sovereignty of the areas is disputed but Phnom Penh claims the territory belongs to Cambodia. Several rounds of bilateral talks so far have failed to break the impasse.


Cambodia closed the border to Thailand at Preah Vihear, north of Siem Reap, in June after Thai protesters gathered in the area, saying it feared trouble with Cambodian settlers.


On July 7 UNESCO granted the 11th-century hilltop Hindu temple World Heritage status over protests by Thailand. Thai troops moved into nearby areas a week later, severely straining relations between the neighbours.//dpa

First Property Expo Set For October


Courtesy of Phnom Penh Post


Written by Nguon Sovan and Hor Hab
Wednesday, 27 August 2008


Hopes are high event will spur interest in housing market

CAMBODIA'S booming real estate market is attracting record interest from property companies with the Kingdom's first-ever real estate expo scheduled for October.

Whale Event Management, a member of Whale Group, expects to be at full capacity when it kicks off the three-day exposition on October 3 at Phnom Penh's Mondial Center, said Sorn Sovattey, senior sales executive for Whale Event Management.

"We expect to have 31 real estate companies registering for the expo, because we have only 31 booths," Sorn Sovattey told the Post.

She said the expo will focus on city developers, realtors, property agents and property development consultants. It will also feature a growing field of designers, contractors and urban planners.

Luxury and high-end real estate developers are especially interested in the Kingdom, which has so far remained sheltered from the property market turmoil in Vietnam and stagnation in Thailand.

"The event is a good chance to gather all real estate companies together, which is easy for customers to see," she said. "It is a premium and high-class expo, which is expected to attract about 40,000 businesspeople, company bosses and customers."

Exhibitors can choose from five categories of booths: diamond, costing US$20,000 for three days, gold ($10,000), silver ($8,000), platinum ($6,000) and standard booths ($2,500).

"The real estate market is improving with a lot of satellite cities," Sorn Sovattey said. "After the 2008 election, the trend will go further."

Nhem Sothea, marketing manager of the Grand Phnom Penh International City, one of the capital's housing mega-projects, said the expo would give developers a chance to reach a wider audience.

"It is a good chance to display real estate products such as house styles, villas, business centers," he said Monday.

Others said the event would allow potential customers to get an overview of Phnom Penh's rapidly evolving housing market by talking directly with developers and real estate agents.

"Customers can see the styles of houses that they prefer and negotiate prices," said Mao Thora, an undersecretary at the Commerce Ministry.

But some realtors have complained that the expo fees are too high and that the event was not planned far enough in advance.

In Sitha, general manager of Sovannaphum Realty, told the Post that his company would visit the event, but not join as an exhibitor.

"My company focuses on land speculation and building development, but I don't have any interest displaying at the expo. We have [other] ways to promote our products, and the expo schedule is too early to arrange for it," he said.

Sung Bonna, president of Bonna Realty Group, said that the initiative is good for the Cambodian market, but timing and costs could curb participation.

"My company has not made a decision yet.... The price for exhibiting is also too high for Cambodia's standards," he said.

Sorn Sovattey acknowledged that it was too early to tell how successful Cambodia's inaugural property expo would be, said she hoped it would be a top draw for the market.

"It is too early, of course, but we hope all real estate companies can participate," she said.

Thailand, Cambodia Agree To Tourism For Preah Vihear Once Military Tensions Ease

Courtesy of Phnom Penh Post
Written by Thet Sambath and Brendan Brady
Wednesday, 27 August 2008


Thai Prime Minister Samak met with Cambodian Defence Minister Tea Banh over the dispute, agreeing to restart tourism to the ancient site after troops leave the area

AFP

Tourists stroll through the ruins at Preah Vihear. Officials hope to draw in more visitors. THAILAND and Cambodia have agreed to cooperate to develop tourism at areas along the border once the military standoff is resolved, Thai Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej said Monday.

The Thai premier made the statement in Bangkok after meeting with Cambodia's defence minister, Tea Banh, who is also a deputy prime minister.

"Territorial problems which cannot be resolved by now will be left for negotiations later," and a "middleman will be appointed to oversee promoting tourism with an aim to bring back tourists," Samak was quoted as saying by the Thai government news service, Thai News Agency (TNA).

He added that the temple cannot be opened to tourism until all military personnel have withdrawn, according to TNA.

Monday's agreement to promote tourism at Preah Vihear temple came after Cambodian Foreign Minister Hor Namhong and his Thai counterpart, Tej Bunnag, failed in talks August 19 and 20 to reach a resolution on the border dispute.

The two sides agreed they would meet again in October pending a survey and demarcation of the area to be carried out by the Joint Border Commission.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I never thought this area would become popular with tourists.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On the Cambodian side, developing tourism at Preah Vihear could give a major boost for a corner of the country long notorious as the last region occupied by Khmer Rouge fighters.

Locals hopeful
The prospect of a tourism boom has enterprising Cambodians in the area licking their lips at the potential windfall.

Tep Savy, 43, an owner of a small guesthouse in Sa Em, about 25 kilometres from the base of the pitted mountain road to the temple, said her village had been an active battlefield between Khmer Rouge and Cambodian military forces since she moved there in 1979.

"I never thought this area would become popular with tourists. It's going to go from a war zone to a tourist boom town," she said.

She said that since the temple's World Heritage listing, her 12-room guesthouses, which before was lucky to see a guest every couple of days, is now regularly fully booked.

She said she planned to add more rooms but would wait for the temple standoff to cool down before making the investment.

Chim Phalla, from Komuoy village at the base of the Dangrek mountain range on which the temple sits, has "high hopes to earn a fortune" by quitting his job as a grocer and opening a restaurant to capitalise on the expected influx of tourist dollars.

Tourism Minister Thong Khon told the Post that the government would develop comprehensive plans to encourage the development of tourism infrastructure for Preah Vihear temple, including road access from Phnom Penh and Siem Reap.

The Unesco listing should also promote Preah Vihear's spot on multinational temple tours through Cambodia, Thailand and Laos, he added.

Infrastructure
Early this month, Prime Minister Hun Sen ordered that the 80 km road connecting Anlong Veng town to Preah Vihear temple be paved as the dispute with Thailand has lent new significance to the ancient ruins of Preah Vihear temple.

The prime minister followed up last week, ordering the construction of a new 9km road from Prey Veng village in Oddar Meanchey province to Ta Moan Thom temple complex, also along the border with Thailand.

Thailand and Cambodia have been locked in a military standoff at the temples for six weeks.

Tensions have eased, but troops are still only yards apart in some disputed areas.

UN Expert Arrives As US Announces It Might Fund The ECCC

Courtesy of Phnom Penh Post
Written by Georgia Wilkins
Wednesday, 27 August 2008


David Tolbert is back in Cambodia, keeping an eye on the Extraordinary Chambers as the US mulls money for the financially troubled court

SPECIAL EXPERT
In April, the UN appointed American lawyer David Tolbert, former deputy prosecutor at the war crimes court for the former Yugoslavia, as “special expert” to the UN secretary general about the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC). THE UN's financial expert to the Khmer Rouge tribunal has arrived in Cambodia on what UN officials are calling a "private" visit to meet with donors and ramp up fundraising efforts for the ECCC.

Tolbert, whose previous visits have been to boost donor confidence in the wake of mismanagement claims, began work Monday and is expected to stay a week, UN spokesman Peter Foster said.

Tolbert was hired by the UN secretary general in April to review the world body's operations at the joint tribunal. His arrival comes as the US announced that it was on the "threshold" of making a decision to fund the struggling tribunal.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

HE WILL BE MEETING WITH KEY PEOPLE FROM THE COURT [AND] THE LOCAL DONOR[S].

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"He will be meeting with key people from the court, the local donor community, and will look at donor contributions and the progress made by the court," Foster said.

He described the visit as "strictly technical", however, and said Tolbert was under no jurisdiction from the UN Development Program.

An appointment for the US?
Tolbert, who couldn't be reached for comment Tuesday, was appointed after Kao Kim Hourn, a secretary of state with the Foreign Ministry, told the UN in January that Washington wanted an advisory role in the tribunal and would consider helping fund the court if given the post.

Kao Kim Hourn later retracted his statement, but the US embassy said that they were likely to meet with Tolbert, although were not sure when.

"We expect there will be an opportunity to speak with the Secretary General's advisor about his activities and the importance to donors of ensuring that advancement of administrative reforms in the ECCC match the judicial progress observed to date," said embassy spokesman John Johnson in an email Tuesday.

Outgoing US Ambassador Joseph Mussomeli said Monday that he thought the corruption issue "will be resolved ... and ultimately [the tribunal] will get funding".

Allegations that Cambodian staff were kicking back a portion of their salaries to higher officials are being reviewed by the UN's Office of Internal Oversight. Hundreds of thousands of dollars in funds have been frozen by the UNDP in the meantime.

The court has repeatedly faced bankruptcy and still faces a more than US$40 million shortfall.

Soldiers Stationed On Border Will Be Given Land, Prime Minister Says

Written by Thet Sambath
Wednesday, 27 August 2008


Govt announces new social land concession for troops in a bid to strengthen border security

HENG CHIVOAN

A Cambodian soldier in Preah Vihear. The government is to give military families land in a bid improve border security. PRIME Minister Hun Sen has called for land concessions to be given to soldiers serving along the Cambodia-Thai border in a move that is hoped to populate the Kingdom's frontier and strengthen it against incursions, the Council of Ministers said.

"Hun Sen's plan is to develop roads throughout the northwest and to provide for soldiers and their families serving in the region," said Council of Ministers spokesman Phay Siphan. "He was a solider, so he understands the needs of soldiers and their family members."

The new plan follows announcements last week that military engineers will build new roads near the Preah Vihear and Ta Moan Thom temple complexes in response to a six-week standoff with Thailand over disputed border territory near the two temples.

San Vanna, deputy governor of Oddar Meanchey province, said the government has instructed him to prepare land for soldiers and their families near bases where they are currently stationed.

"We received orders to prepare land for the military," San Vanna said Monday. "The land is ready and we're working out the details."

Touch Ra, a soldier in Military Region 4 and deputy chief of Chom International Checkpoint, welcomed the plan.

"The prime minister's policy will be good for our soldiers and will encourage them to defend the border and our nation against Thailand," Touch Ra said. "It's an important step toward improving border security and the safety of the whole Kingdom."

A new strategy
Ke Kim Yan, commander-in-chief of the Royal Cambodian Armed Forces, visited soldiers last week at Preah Vihear and Ta Moan Thom temples, as well as in Anlong Veng district to evaluate current plans for new roads along the border.

Opposition lawmaker Cheam Channy welcomed the land concession measure but warned that high-ranking officials could use the opportunity to seize the best real estate for themselves and leave rank-and-file troops with little.

"It's a good idea ... but commanders will take the best land for themselves, while our troops will be left with smaller plots," Cheam Channy said.

Chea Mon, commander of Military Region 4, said provincial authorities, and not the military, would administer the land concessions.

"I am in contact with provincial authorities regarding the concessions, but it is their responsibility to apportion land to military families," he said Monday. He added that he does not know how authorities will ultimately distribute the concessions.

A high-ranking official with the Ministry of the Interior, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorised to talk to the press, said that he had received no instructions about the proposed concessions but that the government has plenty of land waiting to be distributed to landless people.

"We are working to provide land for landless people in Kratie and Kampong Cham provinces, as well as other provinces," the official said. "We want to make sure it's given to the right people, not just military families."

Other measures to better secure border areas are under consideration, according to government spokesman Khieu Kanharith, who responded to a story in the Bangkok Post on Monday about a possible "Berlin-style" wall along the border with Thailand.

In a press release, Khieu Kanharith said a wall had never been proposed but that concrete markers and barriers could be built to help stop smuggling and other cross-border criminal activity, but only in areas agreed to by both countries.

Anti-Corruption Law To Be Given To National Assembly Next Month

Courtesy of Phnom Penh Post

Written by Sebastian Strangio and Vong Sokheng
Wednesday, 27 August 2008

Civil society groups have expressed concern, saying prior drafts were toothless and law will have little impact on graft

HENG CHIVOAN Lawmakers at the National Assembly will receive a copy of the draft anti-corruption law next month.

WITH the National Assembly set to pass its long-awaited anti-corruption law next month, observers have questioned the likely effectiveness of the new legislation, saying it could do little to reduce Cambodia's rampant corruption.

In a press conference Sunday, government spokesman Khieu Kanharith said the draft law will be given to the new CPP-dominated National Assembly shortly after its inauguration on September 24.

But civil society groups said the draft has been difficult to obtain and they are concerned it is based on the draft submitted in 2006, which fell short of international standards."We have not received a new draft from the government, and we do not know of any changes to the [2006] draft law," said Sek Borisoth, director of Pact Cambodia. He said the 2006 draft was a watered-down version of earlier versions, and that its lack of whistleblower protections would hamper its effectiveness. "The fight against corruption will not be successful if the law does not help protect witnesses and whistleblowers," he said.


when we received the draft in 2007, it had no meaning and no real standards.


Sam Rainsy Party spokesman Son Chhay said the SRP had also not received a draft from the government, and assumed the law to be the same that was formulated in 2006.

"I believe [it is the same], but we have not seen it," he said. "It shouldn't be a secret, it should be a public document."Son Chhay said the last draft lacked teeth, putting the responsibility for its enforcement into the hands of a council staffed by government officials.

"When we received the draft in 2007, it had no meaning and no real standards for fighting corruption," he said. "The government was planning to set up a Supreme Council with representatives from across the government.

But if you have representatives from all sections of government, how can you deal with government corruption?" Without amendments to the 2006 draft, he said, "corruption in Cambodia will remain the same.

"However, Song Lim Neou, secretary of state at the Council of Ministers, said the draft had taken other views into account. "The law has been completed and the opinions of civil society and other stakeholders have been included in the final draft." he said.

US Embassy spokesman John Johnson said corruption cost Cambodia millions of dollars each year, and welcomed the new legislation. "We are pleased to hear that the government has announced plans to proceed with the passage of this important law," he said by email.

"We have not had recent conversations with the government on the substance of the draft law, [but] we look forward to seeing a draft of the new law and working with the government in order to pass a version that meets international standards," he said.

Cambodia mulls allowing foreigners to buy property


PHNOM PENH: The Cambodian government is considering allowing foreign ownership of property such as apartments and office buildings to boost the country's economic growth, an official said on Wednesday. Under the current rules, foreign property investments can only be made through the name of a Cambodian national, and many are unwilling to risk losing their assets to unscrupulous local partners.

Information Minister Khieu Kanharith said the government is evaluating the policy to ensure that foreigners will be allowed to own buildings and apartments but not land.

"The important thing is that foreigners cannot own land... They can buy things above the ground only," Khieu Kanharith told. He said that the plan would attract more foreign investment and more skilled foreign workers to the impoverished nation.

"This policy will boost our economic growth," Khieu Kanharith added. The move comes after the private sector last year urged the government to allow foreign ownership of certain properties like apartments or factories, saying a liberalised real estate market would spur the economy. Cambodia's investment law was amended in 2005 to allow foreign ownership of buildings, but the legislation has yet to be implemented and the initiative has floundered. Despite current restrictions, billion-dollar skyscraper projects and sprawling satellite cities promising to radically alter Phnom Penh have bloomed over the past few years.

They are mainly backed by South Korean companies working through local partners. After decades of turmoil, Cambodia has emerged as a rising economy in the region - posting average 11 per cent growth over the past three years on the back of strong tourism and garment sectors. But officials warn that the country, which still relies on international aid for half of its annual budget, must diversify by seeking more varied foreign investments.

Click here to comment on this story.
To read business stories in हिंदी click here.

Monday, August 25, 2008

US envoy urges Asean to take up temple issue

Courtesy of Bangkok Post


Phnom Penh (dpa) - The Association of Southeast Asian Nations could play a key role in resolving an ongoing border dispute between Cambodia and Thailand, outgoing US ambassador to Cambodia Joseph Mussomeli said at a press conference Monday.

Mussomeli, who is ending a three-year mission, said the US favoured a bilateral solution between the two neighbours over disputed territory on the northern Cambodian border.

"Cambodia and Thailand are neighbours and they will stay with each other forever," he told reporters. "Thailand needs Cambodia and Cambodia needs Thailand.

"But if bilateral negotiations fail, if after every effort you cannot find a solution, it is time to consider the option of the United Nations Security Council."

He also said one step that had been overlooked in the negotiation process which could help ensure the dispute was solved within Asian parameters was the 10-member Asean, of which both sides are members.

"That is one thing Asean could do to make itself really effective," he said.

Tensions arose last month shortly after UNESCO declared the 11th-century Preah Vihear temple, around 300 kilometres from the capital, a World Heritage site over Thai objections.

Thailand sent troops into what it says is disputed territory near the temple and Cambodia says is sovereign territory.

At the end of July, Cambodia made fresh claims that Thai troops had also moved into the Ta Moan temple complex, 150 kilometres west, but Thailand disputed that, saying it had held the area for years.

Switzerland does not rule out talking to Osama bin Laden

GENEVA : Switzerland's foreign minister on Monday broke with the country's tradition of studiously discrete diplomacy by raising the possibility of direct talks with Osama bin Laden to tackle global terrorism.

Micheline Calmy-Rey, who has raised both eyebrows and hackles with her controversial style, told Swiss ambassadors gathered in the capital Bern that they needed to talk to "heavyweight political figures" on the world stage even if they are considered persona non grata by other powers.

"It is important to get away from a Manichean view of the world in black and white, where peoples and countries can only be allies or enemies," she said. If this view prevailed, Israel would never have held talks with the Palestinians, Nepal would never have talked to Maoist rebels - and the international community would have boycotted the Olympic Games in Beijing, she said. "So should we listen to these 'wise figures'? Or should we continue dialogue without discrimination - even sitting down at the same table as Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden?," she asked rhetorically.

Calmy-Rey told more than 170 Swiss ambassadors and consular officials meeting this week in Bern that she always favoured dialogue over sanctions and isolation. "The refusal of dialogue is always a sterile choice," she said, adding that for Switzerland, "the only force we have ever had is that of words." Switzerland does not have any list of banned organisations to which it will not talk, unlike other countries. "We talked to Hamas and Hezbollah and other Islamist organisations, we talked to the most diverse groups in Kosovo, because they clearly expressed the legitimate interests of the population," she said. "By doing this, we did not legitimise their methods, but pushed them towards ending violence," she added. Calmy-Rey said that groups as diverse as Hezbollah, the FARC guerrillas in Colombia, Tamil Tiger rebels in Sri Lanka and the Lord's Resistance Army in Uganda are all "essential in the search for a resolution" of different conflicts worldwide. She stressed however that dialogue did not mean "accepting the unacceptable," and conceded that it could sometimes lead to tensions and "complex political blockages.

" Switzerland has played a high-profile role in negotiations with the FARC in Colombia which has caused strains in its relations with Bogota.

Colombian authorities began an inquiry earlier this month into the role of Swiss mediator Jean-Pierre Gontard, suspected by Bogota of handing over a 500,000-dollar (323,000-euro) ransom to the FARC in return for the release of two Novartis employees in 2001. Both Gontard and the Swiss foreign ministry deny the allegation.

The foreign minister's style has sparked a high degree of criticism among domestic political opponents, who have accused her of jeopardising Switzerland's standing in the eyes of key allies.
The United States for example was fiercely critical of a visit by Calmy-Rey to Iran in March for the signing of an energy deal with Iran's state gas company, saying it sent the "wrong message" to Tehran. But Calmy-Rey said that Switzerland still enjoyed "good and constructive" relations with Washington. "Our strength is dialogue, promoting dialogue, and our capacity for taking reasonable risks," Calmy-Rey said. - AFP/de

US to fund Khmer Rouge trial Article from: Agence France-Presse

Article from: Agence France-Presse


From correspondents in Phnom Penh
August 25, 2008 08:13pm

THE United States will give its first donation to Cambodia's cash-strapped Khmer Rouge genocide trial as soon as the UN-backed court resolves corruption allegations, the US ambassador said today.

The tribunal faces a funding shortfall of more than $US40 million ($46.1 million). Officials travelled to New York in June to petition UN members for more funds.

"The United States government is right now on the threshold of making its decision to directly fund the tribunal,'' outgoing Ambassador Joseph Mussomeli told reporters at his farewell press conference at the US embassy.

"I think in Washington now everyone is very much looking forward to finding funding to help directly assist the tribunal if we can just work this last thing out,'' he said.

The Khmer Rouge tribunal this month launched a new ethics monitor to grapple with ongoing claims of corruption within the court after the UN Development Program made fresh allegations of kickbacks on the Cambodian side of the court, forcing international donors to withhold funding for July.

International backers have appeared hesitant to pledge more money to the process after earlier allegations of political interference and mismanagement, including that Cambodian staff paid money in exchange for their jobs.

But tribunal officials have said the allegations last year were "unspecific, unsourced and unsubstantiated.''

The court is preparing for its first trial against Kaing Guek Eav, who ran a notorious torture centre in Phnom Penh.

He is expected in the dock in October, once the court has dealt with the prosecution's appeal of his indictment, which it said failed to present a "full and truthful account'' of his crimes.

In all, five top Khmer Rouge leaders are now facing charges before the tribunal for crimes committed by the regime.

Up to two million people died of starvation, overwork and execution as the communist Khmer Rouge dismantled modern Cambodian society in a bid to forge an agrarian utopia during its 1975-1979 rule.

Friday, August 22, 2008

Jetstar plane slides in the wet

August 22, 2008, 5:55 pm


Jetstar passengers due to fly out of Cambodia were forced to spend another night in the south-east Asian country after the plane slid to the edge of a runway in wet weather as it arrived from Singapore.

The incident occurred on Thursday morning.

Tyres on the left-hand side of the plane were damaged and had to be replaced but none of the 144 passengers flying from Singapore on the A320 were injured, a Jetstar Asia spokesman said.

"The aircraft drifted to the edge of the runway but it was only for a short time and it quickly corrected as normal," he said.

Jetstar put passengers due to fly back to Singapore from Siem Reap-Angkor up in hotels for 24 hours while another flight was organised, the spokesman said.

Prosecutors want more charges against Khmer Rouge prison chief

Courtesy of ABC, Australia

Posted Fri Aug 22, 2008 8:50am AEST

Prosecutors at the UN-backed genocide tribunal in Cambodia are appealing to have additional charges lodged against Comrade Duch, the first of five Khmer Rouge defendants to front court.

The co-prosecutors of the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia want Comrade Duch, also known as Kaing Guek Eav, to face murder and torture charges as allowed by Cambodian law.

As it currently stands, the co-investigating judges have sought only to charge him with crimes against humanity and war crimes.

Duch was head of the notorious Tuol Sleng prison, where thousands of people were detained, tortured and killed in the 1970s under the orders of the Khmer Rouge government.

More than 1 million Cambodians died while the Khmer Rouge was in power from 1975 to 1979.
The outcome of this appeal should be known by the end of September.

The tribunal has been wracked with delays and budget.

The trial against Comrade Duch is expected to get underway in October.

Thai king world's wealthiest royal: Forbes

Courtesy of ABC, Australia.
Posted Fri Aug 22, 2008 8:37am AEST

Forbes magazine says Thailand's King Bhumibol Adulyadej is the world's richest royal sovereign, with a fortune estimated at $US35 billion ($40 billion).

The magazine says oil-rich Sheikh Khalifa Bin Zayed Al Nahyan of Abu Dhabi is second, with $US23 billion.

King Bhumibol, 80 and, at 62 years on the throne the world's longest-serving head of state, pushed to the top of the richest royals list by virtue a greater transparency surrounding his fortune, Forbes said.

It said that the Crown Property Bureau, which manages most of his family's wealth, "granted unprecedented access this year, revealing vast landholdings, including 3,493 acres in Bangkok."
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II was 12th on the list with $US650 million.

-AFP

US troops to pull out of Iraq by 2011: negotiator

Courtesy of ABC, Australia

Negotiators have finalised a deal which will see the complete withdrawal of US troops from Iraq by 2011, ending an eight-year occupation, the top Iraqi heading the team said.

Under the 27-point deal all US combat troops will be withdrawn from Iraqi cities by next June, negotiator Mohammed al-Haj Hammoud said.

The agreement has already been approved by US President George W Bush and now needs to be endorsed by Iraqi leaders, he added.

Iraq and the US had agreed to "withdraw the US troops from Iraq by end of 2011," Mr Hammoud said.

"The combat troops will withdraw from Iraqi cities by June 2009. Both the parties have agreed on this.

"The negotiators' job is done. Now it is up to the leaders."

The security pact will decide the future of US forces in Iraq once the present UN mandate, which provides the legal framework for the presence of foreign forces in Iraq, expires in December.

Bush and Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki had agreed last November to formalise such an agreement by July 31.

The arrangement was delayed due to strong opposition from Iraqi leaders over key issues such as when US combat troops would withdraw from Iraq, how many bases Washington would retain and whether American troops would be immune from Iraqi laws.

Mr Hammoud said all issues had been addressed in the deal.

He added however that there was a possibility that US troops could leave before 2011 or remain beyond the target date.

"There is a provision that says the withdrawal could be done even before 2011 or extended beyond 2011 depending on the [security] situation," he said.

Mr Hammoud said that even if the withdrawal does take place by 2011, some US troops could remain "to train Iraqi security forces".

He said the issue of how many bases the US would retain in Iraq depended on the number of troops left behind for training purposes.

A number of committees would also look into offences committed by American troops in Iraq.
The immunity offered to American soldiers currently in Iraq had been one of the main sticking points in the negotiations which began in February.

In a surprise one-day visit to Iraq on Thursday, US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said the two countries were "very, very close" to finalising the agreement but had not yet clinched the deal.

On Thursday Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari, however, went a step further and said the text of the deal was ready.

"We are very close, we have a text, but not the final agreement. Everything has been addressed," Mr Zebari said.

The deal has drawn sharp criticism from Iraq's political factions, especially from the anti-American group of Shiite cleric Moqtada al-Sadr.

Dr Rice said that the US had been very "flexible" in the negotiations.

"The US has gone very far in this agreement, it is a very advanced agreement," she said.

Any deal would first have to be ratified by the Iraqi parliament and the veto-wielding presidency council.

The White House said on Thursday (local time) that US lawmakers would not be asked to approve the pact.

"It's not a treaty, so it would not require Senate ratification or anything like that," White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe told reporters at Mr Bush's ranch in Crawford, Texas.

With 144,000 American troops currently in Iraq, the issue is politically sensitive in Washington as the November US presidential election draws nearer.
- AFP

McCain stumbles over number of homes



Courtesy of ABC, Australia

Posted Fri Aug 22, 2008 10:37am AEST

Updated Fri Aug 22, 2008 11:15am AEST

"Now think about that. If you don't know how many houses you have, then it is not surprising that you might think the economy was fundamentally strong.


"But if you are like me and you've got one house, or you are like the millions of people who are struggling right now to keep up with their mortgage so they don't lose their home, you might have a different perspective."

For a man painting himself as an ordinary guy who knows how people are hurting because of the economic downturn, it was a giant stumble by the White House contender.


John McCain's presidential campaign is in damage control after he was unable to remember how many houses he and his wife own.


It comes just days after the Republican White House hopeful cracked a joke that being rich in the US meant earning at least $5 million.

His Democratic rival, Barack Obama, has been quick to exploit the blunders, as opinion polls show the economy is still the number one concern of American voters.

With the US economy teetering on the brink of recession and housing foreclosures skyrocketing, Senator McCain was asked by The Politico newspaper how many houses he and his wife Cindy own.


Unable to answer, Senator McCain deflected to the question to his advisers.


"I think, I'll have my staff get to you. I can't tell about that," he said.


The McCain campaign told The Politico that Senator McCain and his wife have "at least four" homes in three states - Arizona, California and Virginia.


It was a green light for Senator Obama to take a jab at Senator McCain's views on the US economy.


"So they asked his staff and he said at least four," Senator Obama said.


"Now think about that. If you don't know how many houses you have, then it is not surprising that you might think the economy was fundamentally strong.


"But if you are like me and you've got one house, or you are like the millions of people who are struggling right now to keep up with their mortgage so they don't lose their home, you might have a different perspective."


Senator Obama and his wife have one house, the family home in Chicago which they bought in 2005 for more than $US1.5 million.


A McCain campaign spokesman Brian Rogers has returned fire, quoted as saying "it's a frickin' mansion, he doesn't tell people that".


Senator McCain and his heiress wife Cindy actually have seven homes, plenty of fodder for a new Obama attack ad.


The ad paints McCain as out of touch with America's economic problems.


"Then again on the same day when asked how many houses he owns, McCain lost track. He couldn't remember," the ad says.


"Well, it is seven. Seven houses and here's one house America can't afford to let John McCain move into," it continues, showing the White House.


Senator McCain has not helped dispel this image.


At a weekend faith forum he made a careless comment when Pastor Rick Warren asked him to define the threshold for considering someone as rich.


"How about $5 million," he said, adding, "I'm sure that comment will be distorted".


The point is, both presidential candidates are far better off than most Americans.


Senator Obama earned $US4 million last year, mostly thanks to royalties from his two books, and Senator McCain's tax returns show he earned $US400,000.


His wife Cindy has not disclosed hers, but as the sole heiress to her father's beer distributorship she is worth an estimated $US100 million.


Based on a report by Kim Landers for AM, on August 22.

Cambodia's athletes seek a better playing field



By Rebecca ByerlyFor CNN


PHNOM PENH, Cambodia (CNN) -- Without proper food, shoes, or support from his government, Hem Bunting, the Cambodian Olympic marathon competitor, prepared for the Olympics and hoped for international support in late July.

"It is hard to compete at an Olympic level when you do not get any support from the government," panted Bunting, 25, who had just run intervals on the bleachers of the dilapidated Olympic stadium in the capital.

A week before the four Cambodian athletes were scheduled to attend the opening of the Olympic Games, the President of the National Olympic Committee of Cambodia, Dr. Thong Kohn, appealed to all companies, suppliers, and donors for the $18,423 needed to send the four athletes and 10 supporters to the games in Beijing. The list included funds for shoes, Olympic uniforms, and pocket money.

A representative of the National Olympic Committee of Cambodia said there was insufficient money for sports. Programs for sports would develop as education in the country improved.

"We need to improve and reform several sectors in Cambodia's education programs," explained Sambath Sothea, who is in charge of the Sports Marketing Program for the Cambodian Olympic Team.

"Part of this improvement should be in sports education, which is an important part of the personal development of young people who are the future of our nation. People have the tendency to forget Cambodia is a nation on the rise and need to give it some time to grow."

Once referred to as the Pearl of Asia, Cambodia's sports programs, economy, and infrastructure were destroyed during the Khmer Rouge reign, where it is estimated that 1.5 million people were killed between 1975 and 1979. The country has only now begun to emerge on the global market, with the country's first stock exchange scheduled to start in 2009.
Bunting believed the only way sports would develop was through private donors.

"If we could get sponsored, we could go somewhere with sports in Cambodia, but the government is not going to support us because they are busy with other things," said the runner, whose best marathon time of 2 hours 26 minutes, 28 seconds placed him second at the Sea Games, a competition held among South East Asian countries.

"I work really hard but do not even have the basic things I need, like nutritious food to eat or clothes for training." Bunting ran on the busy streets of the capital without proper running shoes until the American New Zealand Bank (ANZ) sponsored him.

Sothea believed the partnership between the public and private sector was critical for the development of sports in the country.

"The government needs to reform sports and give it a more reliable structure," said Sothea who earned his law degree in France. "The private sector will be responsible for making investments."

In wake of the recent elections held in the country, which ushered in relative peace and political stability, major investment companies have flocked to Cambodia. Some of these investors considered sports a potential investment opportunity.

"From supporting the training and finances of an Olympic athlete to building industrial parks and helping Cambodia become a leading rice exporter, we want to invest in areas that Cambodians take pride in," said Marvin Yeo, the co-founder of Frontier Investment Partners. Yeo's firm planned to devote over $250 million to an array of areas, which include real estate, infrastructure, manufacturing, and agriculture throughout the next decade.

Another investor was also hopeful about Cambodia's future.

"The next five years will be the time investment takes off in Cambodia and the country starts to put itself on the map," explained Douglas Clayton, founder of Leopard Capital, which manages a private equity fund that invests in Cambodia. "You will see a major change in the country, and things like sports, which have been overlooked because of the lack of government support, may start to receive some funding from the private sector."

From farming to development

The growing interest in sports is another indicator of the country's aptitude for development. Cambodia has begun to see a generation that has taken an avid interest in their educations and future careers.

"Development is good for Cambodia," said Bunting, whose village got electricity only two years ago. "I would not have gotten a good education if it had not been for the foreigners who came to my village and started a school."

Though his parents were poor, uneducated rice farmers, Bunting studied development at Cambodia University and wanted to work with foreign organizations in the remote areas of the country to improve education and infrastructure. His talent for running was first discovered when he competed in a national competition in Phnom Penh several years ago.

Bunting is part of the growing number of youths who are becoming more socially aware in Cambodia.

"The days of the Khmer Rouge are over now, and the youth in Cambodia face different challenges, like how to become socially conscious and have a voice in the development of their country," said Long Kat, 35, the director of Youth for Peace in Cambodia.

While 50 percent of the country's population is under 25, and young people between the ages of 18 and 30 comprise more than 50 percent of eligible voters, they have only recently begun to engage in politics and their communities.

"Cambodia is not competitive in sports, education, or most jobs right now because we don't have any competition and little opportunity in the country," said Bunting. "But I think with the right support this could change."

Bunting said education and employment are the greatest concerns of his generation.

Investment in education

While both of these areas are projected to improve, some individuals remain skeptical of the many flaws that remain in the system. Investors pour in, but some intellectuals' wonder what exactly is being done to improve the educational system and how this will impact the alarmingly high rate of unemployment.

"I lived in Cambodia for five years in the early 90's," exclaimed Clodagh O'Brian, who worked for an NGO in the capital at that time. "The city has transformed with buildings, paved roads, and soon skyscrapers. But, what has not changed that much are the schools. I would like to know how much investment is going back in to education."

Reports of corruption and bribes in schools are common, and children have limited opportunities in the current educational system. Education is one of the areas that Yeo and Clayton claim will improve as a result of the incoming investments.

"You will see growth in some sectors of education," said Clayton, who has worked in Asia over 20 years. "For example, as investors build more hotels in the country, others may start to invest in hotel management schools and language schools. Cambodia will gradually produce more skilled English-speaking workers."

Despite the difficulties posed by the poor infrastructure and the many challenges he faces, Bunting remained optimistic about Cambodia's future. "Being an athlete and just trying to live in Cambodia is not easy," sighed Bunting. "But, I think in several years, it could get better."
Sothea agreed.

"The important thing is not to win, but to take part," quoted Sambeth, who burrowed the philosophy from Baron Pierre De Cobertin, the President of the International Olympic Committee. "Instead of complaining about where Cambodia is we need to have a collective vision for where the country is going. Let's meet up again eight years from now and see where Cambodia and her athletes are

Kuwait loans Cambodia $546 mln, plans embassy

Courtesy of Reuteurs

PHNOM PENH, Aug 22 (Reuters) - Kuwait has agreed to give Cambodia loans totalling $546 million to develop agriculture, build hydro-power facilities and construct roads, a Cambodian foreign ministry official said on Friday.

This is the second-biggest aid pledge ever received by Cambodia, after aid and loans totalling $601 million offered by China last year.

"This is showing a stronger relationship between Kuwait and Cambodia, both political and economic," Cambodian foreign ministry spokesman Sin Bunthoeurn told Reuters late on Thursday after the ministry hosted bilateral ministerial talks.

He said they planned to open embassies early next year. The two countries have had diplomatic ties since 1997.

A Kuwaiti newspaper reported that Kuwait had leased rice fields in Cambodia to secure food supplies after Prime Minister Sheikh Nasser al-Mohammad al-Sabah met Cambodian leaders earlier this month.

Qatar's prime minister, Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim al-Thani, paid his first official visit to Cambodia in April 2008 and Qatar plans to invest $200 million in Cambodian farmland.

Some $486 million from the Kuwaiti loan will be invested in irrigation systems and hydro-power on the Stueng Sen river in the northeastern province of Kampong Thom.

The remaining $60 million will be used for building roads in the northwestern province of Battambang, a rice-growing area, Sin Bunthoeurn said.

Kuwait has signed more than $27 billion of investment agreements with nine Asian countries during an Asian tour this month, its finance minister was reported as saying on Aug. 17.
(Reporting by Ek Madra; Editing by Alan Raybould)
© Thomson Reuters 2008 All rights reserved.

Monday, August 11, 2008

Show of Unity & Voice of Solidairty: Where Would It Head?

My previous article "Merging - The Strong Force & Prominence Political Party" - a personal look into the effect[s] and impact[s] that might bring upon the SRP if the merging is to go ahead with its "Post Election Allies": Human Rights Party, Funcipec and Norodom Ranariddh Party.

There is a strong and clear indication that Funcipec would soon be the 1st party to break away from the pack - quote "Is ready to jump on board and be the junior partner in the 4th mandate government under the leadership of PM Hun Sen".


Now that the clouds of doubts on the possibility "Merging of Post Election Unity As An Imminence Political Party " are indeed disappeared in the far horizon, the remaining 3 political parties from its original pack of 4; shall by now have had in each individual mind and already figured out whether or not that the "Post Election Unity" is still well alive.

This time around the so called "Post Election Unity" has indeed lived a very short live comparing to the post election in 1998 & 2003.

One may now can say - What's a feeling and Adieu Post Election Allies and Unity!


Saturday, August 9, 2008

Boycott: Is It The Best Solution?


By boycotting a swearing ceremony or the 1st session of the parliament would not change the course of any issue[s] concerned at the moment or potential future "Post Election Drama" which was seen and haunted its citizen for the last few elections or any future election[s] in years to come
.


This [boycotting] is similar to the case of a boxer who deadly wants to have a recognition match but is unwillingly to get inside the ring.

The counting was now completed and the results were posted temporary pending any final complaint[s] against the tally by all political parties concerned.

According to the current figures released by the National Election Committee, 6,010,277 actual voters or 75% of the original 8,125,529 registered and eligible voters have turned out to cast theirs ballot on the election day, comparing to the turnout rate of 83% in 2003, in 1998 - 94% and 90% in 1998 and 1993 respectively.

The Cambodian People's Party (CPP) received 3,492,374 or 58.1% while the opposition Sam Rainsy Party (SRP) received 1,316,714 votes or equivalent to 21.90%. The remaining nine parties split the rest - Human Rights Party (HRP) and Norodom Ranariddh Party (NRP) and FUNCIPEC respectively won 397,816, 337,943 and 303,764 votes or is equivalent 6.61%, 5.62% and 5.05%.

On Friday [08/08/2008] lawmakers from SRP, Norodom Ranariddh Party and the Human Rights Party, a combined seat of 31 among them, held a press conference and announce of its intention to boycott the swearing in of new parliamentarians on August 24 claiming that up to 1 million voters were unable to find their names on polling day on July 27, which is compromising the fairness of the elections.

However, Prime Minister Hun Sen, quote "the ceremony will go ahead regardless", despite some constitutional experts have disputed the legality of this move.

Based on the SRP sensivity analysis and yet controversial self-calculated method
, CPP would have on 77 seats (instead of 90 as wrongly proclaimed by the NEC), while SRP, HRP, NRP and FUCNIPEC would have 35, 7, 2 and 2 seats respectively (instead of 26, 3, 2 and 2), which also echoed as a concern by the leader of the EU observers - Mr. Martin Callanan, who once stated that "50,000" voters were left off rolls however that would not have greatly affected the election since early results show a large majority for the CPP.

According to Committee for Free and Fair Elections' [Comfrel] estimation there were 57,000 names were deleted from the rolls ahead of election - the numbers were in line with Mr. Martin Callanan's estimation. The organization also recorded another 1,148 cases of name omission in 17 municipalities and provinces, sometimes with as many as 50 or 100 names missing in one case.

Let say that 100 names were deleted in each case, there were 1,148 cases [recorded by Comfrel] then the numbers of names deleted would be 114,800, therefore total people deleted from the rolls shall be 171,800 [and that is including the 57,000 names estimated by Comfrel].
The numbers [171,800] are indeed much lower that the numbers estimated/claimed by SRP and its allies.

If my understanding is right, this time the boycotting of the swearing in ceremony of new parliamentarians is much to do with the 1 million people who could not cast theirs vote on the election day.

1 million people is quite big in population wise, however, 1 million in voting proportion-sharing wise is not that drastic at all. Nevertheless the numbers of people could not cast theirs vote is remained unchanged.

Based on the SRP sensitive analysis and self-calculated results, clearly suggesting that the 1 million people who could not vote on the election day is to divide between the SRP and HRP only. and therefore if NEC to re-adjust its result based on that scenario then SRP is said to have extra 9 seats up from 26 to 35 while HRP is said to have 4 up from 3 to 7 as proclaimed by the NEC.

My question is "Why and How" one is so sure that these 1 million people, if theirs name were not stroked off the rolls, are indeed the supporters of two particular political parties only.
Is there any concrete evidence[s] and logical explanation to justify such a claim?

If one side of the equation could easily make such a claim then the other side of the equation [9 political party concerned] would surely can say the same thing or present theirs method of calculation.

The truth is in the hand of those 1 million people and none of the political party could ever pre-sense or so sure that those ballots would indeed go to this or that particular party due to the fact that majority of voters would never want to reveal their identity, make their intention heard publicly, isn't it the case?

I do recall that ever since the rejection of election result, SRP has publicly announced and called upon each individual [if not all 1 million people] to come forwards with a promise of US$ 50 reward so that SRP and its ally could have a legal and legitimated point to argue with NEC on alleged claim of vote rigging and that it is in fact they were theirs supporters and they would definitely vote for the SRP and HRP.

By all means, it is a democratic way and act that all political parties concerned shall protest against any election result on ground of a lawful act in according to the election law. However, if this [protest] is indeed a case of and that because one party is said to believe and claim that the deleted names are surely their supporters or potential supporters then there is, of course, no concrete evidence[s] or logical explanation to justify such a protest.

By boycotting a swearing ceremony or the 1st session of the parliament would not change the course of any issue[s] concerned at the moment or potential future "Post Election Drama" which was seen and haunted its citizen for the last few elections or any future election[s] in years to come.
This [boycotting] is similar to the case of a boxer who deadly wants to have a recognition match but is unwillingly to get inside the ring.

Parliament is the actual legal and lawful ring where all law makers shall have their match and bout - pushing/proposing for any amendment of bill[s] and law[s] in particular the "Election Law", put each other under microscope - checks and balances and to pressure the ruling party/government to perform better.

30% in margin is really a big gap between the "Winner and Runner-up"
and according to Mr. Martin Callanan - "This would not have greatly affected the election since early results show a large majority for the CPP".

It is time that politicians from all equations shall have "Political Will", particularly, the "Opposition Party[ies]" to stand up and concede defeat then move on.

5 years seems a long way to go for another shot at the top job but in fact it is too short [time] if one failed to look back at what went wrong [during this election] and do their best to get the party's platform and policy ready on time for the election.

Thursday, August 7, 2008

Post Election: The Stand Off & Deadlock

This [stand-off & death-lock] is not the first or the last time that Cambodia is facing, in fact it would be an imminent issue and obstacle for Cambodian politicians from all sides if there was not any "Political Will".


Constitution

Here are some articles of the the constitution regarding the formation of a new government.
  • Article 76 stipulated, "Assembly consists at least 120 members".

  • Article 78-

  • The legislative term of the Assembly shall be 5 years and terminates on the day when the new assembly convenes.
  • The assembly shall not be dissolved before the end of its term except when the Royal government is twice deposed within a period of twelve months. In this case, following a proposal from the Prime Minister and the approval of t he Assembly President, the King shall dissolve the Assembly.
  • The election of a new assembly shall be held no later than 60 days from the date of dissolution. During this period, the Royal government shall only be empowered to conduct routine business.

Article 82-

  • The assembly shall hold its first session no later than sixty days after the election upon notice by the King.

  • Before taking office, the assembly shall decide on the validity of each member's mandate and vote separately to choose a President, Vice- Presidents and members of each Commission by a 2/3 majority vote

  • All assembly members must take the oath before taking office according to the text contained in Annex 5.


Death lock

On one hand, the current emerged winner - the Cambodia People's Party who won a land slide victory in the 27th July 2008 election, would not able to form a government on a particular set date - is said to schedule for 26th September, should the dead lock is remaining at its current.


On the other hand, the Sam Rainsy Party - the main "Opposition Party" who managed to pick another 2 seats [26 seats in total] has protested the election result and joined hand in hand with other minority parties - Human Rights Party, Funcipec and Nodom Rannariddh Party, with clear intention that they will boycott the swearing in ceremony.

Accordance with Article 76 of the constitution stipulated that "Assembly consists at least 120 members". Clearly, the winning party - Cambodia People's Party does not have the required numbers.

Article 82 stipulated that "The assembly shall hold its first session no later than sixty days after the election upon notice by the King". So the said scheduled date of 26th September 2008 for the 1st session/swearing in ceremony would not be realized should the death-lock remain.

Voice of Unity and Solidarity

Just day after the election, all 4 minority parties - SRP, HRP, Funcipec and RNP [Four parties united in rejecting election results * Four Main Parties Reject 'Sham' Election * Four Major Political Parties Reject Election Results - posted by KI-Media] joined hand in hand and declared its unity and solidarity “We are uniting with the people to struggle for a re-election nationwide”, which was similar to the previous voice of unity and solidarity as seen during the post election of 1998 and 2003 between the then President of Funcipec - Prince Norodom and Mr. Sam Rainsy except this time around there are two extra voices represented [Prince Nordom Ranariddh is President of NRP and the newcomer HRP].

Cambodia nationwide have twice in the past witnessed the start of the formation of Unity and heard enough of the voice of solidarity, particular those followers and supporters of Funcipec and SRP, and they surely also witnessed how the formation and voice were short live.

For curiosity! Just wondering how long this voice of unity and solidarity would last?

Is it possible that 4 political party mentioned early on can eventually unite and have their dream realized - merging as a strong force and a prominent opposition party to contest in 2013 election.

Issues over the death lock

There are many issues concerned and caused the death-lock.

It was ranging from intimidation, vote buying, illegal and fraudulent practices, which was including the deletion of “countless” eligible voters’ names, to an artificial increase in CPP votes due to distribution of fake voter ID forms which was claimed by the Opposition that would pave way for “ghost voters” to take part, the legitimate and validity of the 1018 form, which were issued on the election day. On top of all these the opposition was accusing NEC for manipulating and helping the CPP to rig the election.

International and local observers' points of views and statements

The leader of the EU observers, Martin Callanan

The poll was marred by the CPP's domination of media coverage and the improper deletion of people from registration lists so they could not vote.

The campaign was generally conducted in a more peaceful and open environment compared to previous elections, but it had fallen short of a number of key international standards for democratic elections

Found evidence that the 1018 voter ID forms were being illegally distributed by CPP-aligned village chiefs to voters, despite the fact that their ID cards showed they had different identities, effectively allowing voters to either vote twice or ineligible voters to take part

50,000 voters were left off rolls and that would not have greatly affected the election since early results show a large majority for the CPP.

On the basis of the provisional results published so far, CPP very clearly has a large majority and therefore any irregularities would have to be of a very large scale to invalidate the result

While it is fair to say we have some evidence of irregularities these are not of such significant scale

“Cambodian People are to be congratulated for the peaceful and orderly way in which they turned out to vote … in a clear demonstration of their commitment to democracy”

Head of the Asian Network For Free Elections (ANFREL) - Ms. Somsri Hananuntasuk

Calling for an investigation and "a serious penalty" for manipulation of the vote

The election was maybe free, but not fair at all

The main problem was people being deleted from voter lists, while there also needed to be limits on campaign financing and the ruling party's control of media

The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights

Lower violence from previous elections but threats, intimidation and inducements directed against political activists to get them to change parties

The Japanese Embassy's statement

No violent activities, intimidation or irregularities that may undermine the overall credibility of the election.
The 2008 National Assembly election has shown an impression internally and externally for its democratic advancement in the Kingdom of Cambodia

The Neutral and Impartial Committee for Free and Fair Elections in Cambodia

The election had been administered well and largely free of intimidation and violence, but the election was also "marred" by a number of irregularities, including the mission of a "significant" number of voter names from registries.

US Embassy - spokesman John Johnson

While there appeared to be "some irregularities," the "vast majority" of Cambodians were able to express their will."

The effects [death-lock may bring upon the nation]

It depends how one would closely look into the situation itself, however, there would be definitely certain effects whether they are medium or serious, but would drastically and inevitably impact on the livihood of its citizen as whole.

One of the greater impact is the potential Direct Foreign Investment, it seemed that many potential invetors would have to put on hold at this stage - until further political progress and that is subjected to any negotiation amongst all political parties concerned.

The first batch of oil and gas drilling may also be effected by the stand-off.

It would also impact on the the border stand-off [Thai-Cambodia].

Conclusion:

Even if a government were to go ahead, Sam Rainsy said his party, which won as
many as 27 seats Sunday, would maintain a strong opposition voice in the National Assembly."There is enough voice to pressure the government to do a better job

Click here for original and full story "We will go to the seat and serve the interests of voters by not giving up all the results we received, even though it was fraudulent."

Based on the above comment, I do beleive that Mr. Sam Rainsy does have a political wills to resolve the death-lock. It is a matter of when and how Mr. Sam Rainsy wants to commit it.